Mary Catherine’s Antiques in Columbus, Ohio
Book an appointment and you’re welcomed into a quiet, home-based showroom in Clintonville where pieces are grouped thoughtfully, the way a seasoned dealer arranges a room. Expect time to look closely and ask questions, since visits are one-on-one and the selection shifts with each buying trip and estate intake.
Mary Catherine’s Antiques is a longtime Columbus name, now operating by appointment and through occasional seasonal sale days announced in advance. After nearly four and a half decades as a Short North storefront, the business transitioned in 2023 to a private Clintonville space and an online catalog. That change didn’t narrow the lens. The mix still reflects a general-line antiques dealer’s eye, with furniture, artwork, lighting, glass and crystal, and the kind of oddities that make collectors smile.
Browsing here feels more like a focused hunt than a stroll through a mall. You might see a barrister bookcase next to Waterford stemware, a Victorian chair beside a midcentury globe, or a local artist’s print propped with carved oak. Inventory is curated rather than massed, so the visit rewards conversation about provenance and condition as much as it does poking around the shelves. If you like to preview, the shop maintains current highlights online and will point you to what’s on hand when you schedule.
Owner Melaine Mahaffey also buys and consults, handling everything from single standout pieces to partial and full estates. That side of the business helps keep the rotation lively and makes appointments useful whether you’re furnishing a room, filling a collection, or deciding what to do with inherited pieces.
- Location: Clintonville, Columbus
- How to shop: By appointment; occasional seasonal sale days announced in advance
- Also available: Online listings and inquiries
- Known for: Eclectic antiques and home decor spanning furniture, art, lighting, and glass/crystal
- History: Operated as a Short North storefront from 1979 to 2023 before moving to the current appointment-based model
If you want a calm, conversation-friendly antiques visit with a curated mix rather than endless aisles, this setup is a good fit, especially if you plan ahead to reserve time.
Published: September 9, 2026 · Reviewed by the Whats Up Columbus editorial team