More Articles
Jewelry store display

Carioti Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio

The cases are modest and close at hand, and much of the work happens just a few steps away. Carioti Jewelers keeps most repairs and custom work in-house, so when you stop in you’re talking with the people who will actually handle your piece.

Family owned and operated, the shop traces its roots to 1991 and later built out a dedicated showroom in 2009. The focus is straightforward: engagement rings and wedding bands, custom design, careful repairs, and appraisals. If you’re comparing diamonds or trying to translate a sketch into a finished setting, staff take time to explain the options before they head to the bench.

Custom design is a regular part of the workflow here. Bring an idea, a stone, or a legacy piece and they’ll walk through metals, setting styles, and timelines. The repair station handles the unglamorous but essential fixes too, from sizing and re-tipping to restoration and clasp replacements, handled by an experienced goldsmith.

For documentation and insurance, appraisals are offered on site and by appointment, with a GIA Graduate Gemologist available to evaluate pieces and prepare paperwork. That setup means many customers can get guidance, service, and documentation in a single visit without sending jewelry off-site.

The showroom sits on Cleveland Avenue in the heart of downtown, serving Central Ohio shoppers who prefer a face-to-face conversation about a significant purchase. Walk-ins are welcome for browsing and basic services. If you’re ring shopping or planning a custom project, the team suggests booking time so they can prepare stones, settings, or design references in advance.

  • Location: 175 Cleveland Ave, Downtown Columbus
  • Typical hours: Mon 9 am–5 pm; Tue 9 am–5 pm; Wed 9 am–4 pm; Thu 9 am–5 pm; Fri 9 am–5 pm
  • Saturday: by appointment only
  • Walk-ins: welcome; appointments recommended for engagement and wedding-band consultations
  • Services: custom design, in-house repair, on-site appraisals with a GIA Graduate Gemologist
  • Founded: 1991; showroom added in 2009
  • Phone: 614-221-8588

If you want a downtown jeweler where you can discuss design at the counter and have most work handled on site, this is a practical place to start.

Published: September 9, 2026 · Reviewed by the Whats Up Columbus editorial team