Bavellie's Pizzeria in Columbus: What's on the Menu, What It Costs, and How It Compares
A neighborhood pizzeria operating out of Columbus's east side, Bavellie's Pizzeria builds its menu around New York-style pies sold by the slice or whole, with a short list of subs and appetizers rounding out the order options.
What Bavellie's Actually Serves
The core of the menu is pizza, and the style leans traditional: hand-tossed dough, straightforward red sauce, and toppings that cover the classics without pushing into novelty territory. Pepperoni, sausage, and combination pies are the steady sellers. The crust hits that middle ground between thin and thick — enough structure to fold a slice without it going limp, but not the dense bread-forward base you'd get from a Sicilian-style spot.
Slices are available during regular service hours, which makes Bavellie's a practical option when you want pizza without committing to a full pie. Pricing sits in the accessible range for Columbus pizza — expect to pay in the neighborhood of $10–$14 for a standard large cheese or pepperoni, with specialty pies running slightly higher. Slice prices typically land around $2.50–$3.50 depending on the topping load. Confirm current prices directly, as these can shift with ingredient costs.
The sub menu is short but functional — the kind of add-on that works when someone in your group isn't feeling pizza. Nothing on the menu is trying to be a fine-dining experience, and that's the point.
How It Fits Into the Columbus Pizza Landscape
Columbus has no shortage of pizza options across every price point and style. Comparing Bavellie's to a few nearby alternatives helps clarify where it belongs.
Iacono's Pizzeria, also on the east side of Columbus, occupies similar territory — neighborhood-scale, slice-friendly, no-frills setup with a loyal local following. The main practical difference is geographic: depending on where you are in the 43213 or 43227 zip codes, one may simply be closer than the other.
For wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, places like Harvest Pizzeria in German Village or Forno Kitchen + Bar near the Short North operate in a different register entirely. Those spots come with higher price tags (expect $15–$20+ for a personal pie), a more curated atmosphere, and a style of crust that prioritizes char and chew over foldability. Bavellie's doesn't compete with those restaurants and isn't trying to.
If you're comparing Bavellie's to chain options in the same price range — your local Donatos, for instance, which is a Columbus original with dozens of locations across the city — the difference is mostly about the experience. Donatos offers edge-to-edge pepperoni, a reliable product, and easy online ordering infrastructure. Bavellie's trades on the feel of an independent shop and the kind of slight variation that comes with pizzas made in smaller batches.
Who This Place Suits
Bavellie's works well for east-side Columbus residents who want a reliable pizza pickup without driving across town. It suits families, people ordering for a group without complicated dietary requirements, and anyone who wants a few slices for lunch without a long wait.
It's less suited to diners looking for specialty dietary accommodations — dedicated gluten-free crust options or robust vegan cheese aren't what this type of operation typically emphasizes. It's also not the right call if you're planning an occasion meal or want to linger over a bottle of wine.
What a First Visit Involves
Walk-in ordering is standard. You can call ahead for whole pies, which is useful during busier evening hours when wait times can extend on a Friday or Saturday. The space is a pickup-focused operation rather than a sit-down dining room, though basic seating is available.
First-time visitors should look at what's already available by the slice before ordering a full pie — if the combination or sausage slice is already up, you're eating in under five minutes. Ordering a custom pie from scratch takes roughly 15–20 minutes.
Hours, Parking, and Logistics
Bavellie's Pizzeria is located on the east side of Columbus. Street or lot parking is generally easy at this type of stand-alone east-side location. Hours have typically followed a late-morning to evening schedule, closing earlier on Sundays than on weekdays or Saturdays. Because independent pizzerias do adjust their hours, checking Google or calling ahead before a late-night trip is the practical move.
Payment by card is accepted, and phone orders are the most reliable way to time a pickup when you're coming from across the neighborhood.