Bavellie's Pizzeria near Columbus, Ohio
The first slice here isn’t really a slice. Order a pie and it arrives cut into tidy squares that make it easy to pass a few around the table while you keep one hand on a calzone cooling beside you. My usual is a square-cut pepperoni pizza with a cheese calzone on the side, the kind of combo that travels well if you’re bringing dinner back toward the city.
Bavellie’s Pizzeria is a Central Ohio outfit known for thin, square-cut pies and hearty calzones, along with a familiar spread of subs, salads, wings, and appetizers. The menu covers the bases for a weeknight order or a small group: create-your-own pizzas with plenty of topping options, a handful of specialty combinations, and calzones that come out with a browned, bubbly crust.
It operates in nearby Newark and Johnstown, which puts it within an easy drive from the east side of Columbus. You can grab a table, call ahead for takeout, or set up delivery depending on which location you’re using. The vibe is straightforward and family-night friendly, and the food holds up if you’re taking it on the road.
If you’re deciding what to try first, start simple. The square-cut pepperoni shows off the crisp edge and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio this place is known for, and pairing it with a calzone or a side of garlic bread rounds out the order without overcomplicating things.
- Known for: square-cut pizzas and calzones
- What they serve: pizza, subs, calzones, salads, wings, appetizers
- How to order: dine-in, takeout, and delivery at operating locations
- Where: locations in Newark and Johnstown, east of Columbus
- Hours: evenings; hours vary by location, check ahead
If a thin, square-cut pizza is what you’re after and a short drive east of the city works for you, Bavellie’s fits the brief.
Published: September 9, 2026 · Reviewed by the Whats Up Columbus editorial team