Does Don Tequila Deserve Its Reputation as a Good Mexican Restaurant in Columbus?

Yes, Don Tequila is generally well-regarded among Columbus diners looking for sit-down Mexican food at a mid-range price point.

The restaurant operates multiple Columbus-area locations, including spots in Gahanna and on the east side, making it accessible to residents outside the Short North or Downtown core. The menu leans toward Tex-Mex staples: fajitas, enchiladas, burritos, and a broad selection of margaritas that justify the name. Entrees typically fall in the $12–$20 range, and the margarita menu is a consistent draw, with house options usually starting around $8–$10 (prices can shift, so confirm on-site or via their current menu).

Compared to other Columbus Mexican options, Don Tequila sits comfortably between fast-casual spots like Condado Tacos and more upscale regional Mexican restaurants like Condesa or Doña. It's a reliable choice when the priority is a full-service experience with table-side guacamole and a decent bar rather than the most authentic regional cooking.

The service and food consistency tend to draw positive reviews on Google, where several locations hold ratings around 4.0–4.3 stars. If you're near Gahanna or the east side and want a reliable Mexican dinner without downtown parking hassle, it's a practical option worth trying.